Daniel P. Molloy, a biologist, examining rocks at Sleepy Hollow Lake in Athens, N.Y., for zebra mussels. He is a pioneer in developing environmentally safe control agents. Credit: L. Mann/APO Sleepy Hollow Lake
Athens, NY, May 1, 2014 - Sea Grant research has helped develop a safe, effective, patented biocontrol agent for zebra and quagga mussels that is cheaper than traditional control methods. Since their introduction into North American waters, zebra mussels (Dreissena polymorpha
) and later quagga mussels (Dreissena rostriformis
) have established themselves as costly aquatic invasive species. By forming dense colonies on hard surfaces through attachment with their byssal threads, these mussels have clogged the pipes and waterworks of numerous facilities. The control and maintenance involved with keeping pipes clear has added to operating costs.
New York Sea Grant funded research led by Dr. Daniel Molloy
of the New York State Museum, to develop an environmentally safe and cost effective control agent of dreissenid mussels. The research involved a promising strain of Pseudomonas fluorescens
, a common soil bacteria that earlier research showed produces a toxin that kills invasive dreissenid mussels.
Molloy’s experiments demonstrated that the bacterial strain CL0145A kills the mussels by producing a biotoxin rather than through infection. The biotoxin is specific to dreissenid mussels and does not harm other mollusks or aquatic species. The work further provided information on effective bacterial culture methods that yield quantities of the biotoxin.
Results from Molloy’s Sea Grant project led to further research funded by the National Science Foundation that allowed testing of the bacterial biotoxin in more realistic settings such as water pipe systems. Further refinement yielded a commercial patented product for the biocontrol of zebra mussels in enclosed water systems which is available for sale as the product Zequanox from Marrone Bio Innovations.
New York, Pennsylvania, Connecticut and Vermont have each issued a Certificate of Pesticide Registration for use of Zequanox to control zebra and quagga mussels in enclosed systems and infrastructures. Approved by the US Environmental Protection Agency in 2012, Zequanox now offers water treatment facilities and businesses such as energy producers and manufacturing companies, an effective and safe alternative to expensive and toxic, broad-spectrum chemicals, mechanical removal and UV light systems to control populations of invasive mussels.
Lane Smith, NYSG Research Coordinator
A cluster of invasive zebra mussels attached to a native
freshwater mussel from Lake Carlos in Minnesota. Such infestations lead
to the larger mussel’s death. Credit: D. P. Molloy/University at Albany
More Info: New York Sea Grant
New York Sea Grant (NYSG), a cooperative program of Cornell University
and the State University of New York, is one of 33 university-based
programs under the National Sea Grant College Program (NSGCP) of the
National Oceanic and Atmospheric Administration (NOAA). The NSGCP
engages this network of the nation’s top universities in conducting
scientific research, education, training and extension projects designed
to foster science-based decisions about the use and conservation of our
aquatic resources. Through its statewide network of integrated
services, NYSG has been promoting coastal vitality, environmental
sustainability, and citizen awareness about the State’s marine and Great
Lakes resources since 1971.
For updates on Sea Grant activities: www.nyseagrant.org
has RSS, Facebook
, and YouTube
links. NYSG also offers a free e-list sign up via www.nyseagrant.org/coastlines
for NY Coastlines
, its flagship publication, which, in 2014, merges with the program's e-newsletter, Currents
. NY Coastlines
is published several times a year.
Science Takes On a Silent Invader
By Robert H. Boyle, The New York Times
In contrast to adults whose shells are always firmly attached to substrates like rocks, the larval veliger stages of zebras mussels, prolific aquatic invasive species in the U.S. Great Lakes, swim freely in water currents for several weeks.
Athens, NY, February 24, 2014 - Since they arrived in the Great Lakes in the 1980s, two species of mussels the size of pistachios have spread to hundreds of lakes and rivers in 34 states and have done vast economic and ecological damage.
These silent invaders, the quagga and zebra mussels, have disrupted ecosystems by devouring phytoplankton, the foundation of the aquatic food web, and have clogged the water intakes and pipes of cities and towns, power plants, factories and even irrigated golf courses.
Now the mussels may have met their match: Daniel P. Molloy
, an emeritus biologist at the New York State Museum in Albany and a self-described “Bronx boy who became fascinated by things living in water.”
Inspired by Rachel Carson’s “Silent Spring” in high school, Dr. Molloy, now 66, has long been a pioneer in the development of environmentally safe control agents to replace broad-spectrum chemical pesticides.
Leading a team at the museum’s Cambridge Field Research Laboratory in upstate New York, he discovered a bacterium, Pseudomonas fluorescens
strain CL145A, that kills the mussels but appears to have little or no effect on other organisms.
As a result, New York State has awarded a license to Marrone Bio Innovations, a company in Davis, Calif., to develop a commercial formulation of the bacterium. The product, Zequanox, has been undergoing tests for several years, with promising results. (Dr. Molloy has no financial ties to the company.)
Zequanox killed more than 90 percent of the mussels in a test using tanks of water from Lake Carlos in Minnesota, said James A. Luoma, a research biologist with the United States Geological Survey in La Crosse, Wis. A control group of freshwater mussels, unionids from the Black River in Wisconsin, were unharmed.
In 2011, the federal Environmental Protection Agency reported that P. fluorescens
CL145A presented “little risk to nontarget organisms.” The agency is now evaluating proposed open-water uses for Zequanox.
Natives of Eastern Europe in the genus Dreissena
, zebra and quagga mussels began moving up the Volga River toward Western Europe 200 years ago. Highly prolific, they attach themselves to boats or any hard surface with their byssus, or beard. They can live out of water for two weeks, and their larvae, known as veligers, use currents to colonize new waters. As many as 700,000 mussels can pile up in a square yard.
Both species are thought to have arrived in North America in the ballast of trans-Atlantic cargo ships. By 1991 they appeared in the Hudson River, and within a year there were 500 billion between Troy and West Point, said David L. Strayer, an ecologist with the Cary Institute of Ecosystem Studies in Millbrook, N.Y.
The tiny mussels became a dominant species in the Hudson. Not even counting their shells, their total weight exceeded that of all the fish, plankton and bacteria combined, Dr. Strayer said, adding that they filtered “a volume of water equal to that of all the water in the estuary every one to four days.” There were no natural enemies to keep them in check.
None, that is, except scientists like Dr. Molloy. His fascination with water goes back to childhood summers on Lake Hopatcong, in New Jersey, where his father, an Irish-born lieutenant in the New York Fire Department, had built a cottage.
In 1956, when Dan was 8, his father and five other firefighters were killed when a wall collapsed in a storefront blaze — still the department’s worst disaster in the Bronx. Their children were given scholarships to Fordham University; the young Mr. Molloy got his bachelor’s and master’s degrees in biology at Fordham, and in 1972 entered the doctoral program at the State University College of Environmental Science and Forestry at Syracuse.
There he began working with State Museum scientists on one of their most vexing research challenges: finding an environmentally safe way to control a plague of black flies in the Adirondacks, where swarms and slashing bites were making life and tourism unbearable in the spring and early summer.
He began by converting a ramshackle fish hatchery in Cambridge, about 40 miles north of Albany, into what is now an internationally recognized field laboratory.
“I was in biocontrol doctoral research heaven,” he said, “getting $25 a day to pursue the kind of problem I wanted to solve.”
Dr. Molloy concentrated on finding agents that could kill the black fly larvae in streams before the adults emerged. He had no luck with natural parasites, but then he heard that a bacterial subspecies called Bacillus thuringiensis israelensis
, or Bti, discovered in a stagnant pond in the Negev desert in Israel, appeared to kill the larvae of black flies as well as those of mosquitoes.
Three years of intensive lab and field trials by Dr. Molloy, part of an international scientific effort, demonstrated Bti’s effectiveness and environmental safety. It is now widely used in place of chemical pesticides throughout North America.
In 1990, when Dr. Molloy learned that invasive mussels had infested New York power plants, he began looking for a bacterium that could do to them what Bti did to black flies.
The odds were against him, he recalls. There were thousands of potential candidates, and a single species of bacterium can have multiple strains that produce widely different effects. Nor was there any guarantee that any of them could control mussels.
The project took Dr. Molloy and his team, in particular his colleague Denise A. Mayer
, 20 years of work in New York and Europe. His lab received more than $4 million in grants from the state, the National Science Foundation, the environmental program New York Sea Grant
, electrical power utilities and other sources. (He was awarded $8,626 for travel and research by the Hudson River Foundation for Science and Environmental Research in 1994, when this reporter was on its board.)
In 1995, after four years of testing more than 700 bacterial strains, excited staff members called Dr. Molloy into the lab. “Strain CL145A,” a bacterium he had collected in river mud, was killing zebra mussels. It turned out to be a strain of P. fluorescens
“A toxin in the strain’s dead cells destroys the digestive system in a mussel,” he explained later. “Dead cells are equally lethal as live cells, providing clear evidence that the mussels die from an intoxicating natural product, not from infection.”
By contrast with caustic chemicals like chlorine, which cause the mussels to quickly shut their valves, the bacterium seems to travel normally through their inhalant siphons and into their digestive tracts. “Although ingestion of CL145A cells is clearly suicidal behavior for the mussels,” Dr. Molloy said, “they appear to have no adverse reaction” when they first feed on the cells.
Compared with chemical agents, he continued, “the effectiveness and environmental safety of this bacterial strain have proved extraordinary.”
Recently retired from the State Museum, Dr. Molloy is now a research biologist at the University at Albany, where he is assembling an international team of scientists to take on a new challenge: Haplosporidia
, spore-forming parasites that have plagued bivalves worldwide.
There are more than 40 species, including the notorious Haplosporidium nelsoni
MSX, which has devastated oyster populations in the Chesapeake Bay and along the Atlantic Coast. No one has been able to figure out how the spores spread infection from one host to another.
Dr. Molloy’s team has discovered a freshwater version of the parasites, H. raabei
, that infects zebra mussels, and will try to understand its life cycle.
It is another daunting scientific challenge. But failure, Dr. Molloy said, “is not an option.”